Futarchy Labs · research on decision markets

Markets that answer “what if?”

Most markets tell you what something is worth. We study markets that tell you what it would be worth under each choice a group could make. We build them, run them with real money, and publish the code.

What we research

Markets as instruments for reasoning: what a group believes, how its beliefs fit together, and what its choices are worth.

Bayesian-network markets

Every question is a variable in one network. Move a probability, or a conditional one, and an inference engine keeps all the prices consistent.

Open Bayes Market

Decision markets

One asset priced once per choice. The gap between the prices is the market's estimate of what the decision is worth.

See the markets

Markets for AI agents

Teams of autonomous agents whose choices are made by internal markets instead of a fixed chain of command.

Agents

Mechanism design

How much money a market needs behind it, who should supply it, and what it costs to push a price the wrong way. Tested in simulation first.

Simulations

How the markets work

A price is a forecast that someone paid to make.
We design markets where those forecasts answer the questions a decision depends on.

Bayes Market links questions in one network

Traders can say "if A happens, B is 70% likely", not only "B is 40% likely". A belief about one question updates the questions it bears on, the way it would in a careful forecaster's head.

Central bank cuts ratesin March?62%Oil above $100this year?18%Recessionnext year?27%Move one probability and the linked ones update. Illustrative numbers.

Open Bayes Market

A decision market prices one stock under each choice

Each trade only counts in the world it was made for and is undone otherwise, so every price is an honest answer to "what if this is chosen?".

The stock today$162If candidate A is chosen$165+1.9%If candidate B is chosen$160−1.2%If nobody is chosen$1620.0%The differences are what the market thinks each choice is worth. Illustrative numbers.

Live: who is the next CEO of NVIDIA?

People trade instead of voting

Anyone who thinks a price is wrong can correct it and is paid if they were right. Knowledge moves the price whoever holds it.

Arbitrage keeps the prices honest

Today's price has to equal the chance-weighted average of the prices under each choice. When it does not, correcting it is profitable.

Field experiments

Each of these ran with real money, and each asked the same kind of question about a different decision.

Code

  • bayes-marketBayesian prediction market engine, event-sourced and combinatorial
  • simulationsMechanism-design simulations for decision markets
  • agentsAgent teams governed by markets
  • fire-the-ceoRobin Hanson's fire-the-CEO decision markets
  • futarchyConditional markets with two or more options

Talks and writing

Guided by the Inventor of Futarchy

Robin Hanson - Chief Scientific Officer

Robin Hanson created the concept of futarchy in 2000 - using prediction markets for governance. As a professor at George Mason University and research associate at Oxford's Future of Humanity Institute, he developed the foundational theory of how markets can make better decisions than traditional voting or expert opinions. His paper "Shall We Vote on Values, But Bet on Beliefs?" shaped the field.

"To embed such markets in the core of our form of government, we could 'vote on values, but bet on beliefs.'"
2000
Robin Hanson introduces futarchy, governance through prediction markets.
Futarchy

Major events shouldn't surprise us.
Neither should their impact.

Open Bayes Market